Cages
McKean
Kitchen Sink Press/NBM , 1998

An amazing visual experience. What more may one expect of a comix book? In his five hundred page masterpiece Cages Dave McKean succeeds in subtly, unforgettably enchanting the retina of his readers. Cages offers the pinnacle of what comix - and visual art in general - have to offer. It opens a new look on reality, a new way of seeing. Enough superlatives. What exactly does McKean offer to deserve them?

Cages


Surprisingly little, in fact: a rented house, a writer, a cat, a recipe for ratatouille. Everyday affairs, with which the young painter Leo Sabarski is confronted, after he has taken residence in a new apartment. Slowly yet certainly Sabarski discovers his new surroundings, slowly yet certainly the readers discover with him the magic of the everyday. Quite adroitly the graphic virtuoso McKean manages to balance between legibility and abstraction, description and imagination.

In many comix the panels serve solely a narrative function. Legibility and straight denotation reign supreme. It is an aesthetic view proposed by, for instance, Will Eisner in his classic books on comix as a ‘sequential art', or stated by Art Spiegelman when he likens comix panels to diagrams. According to this view of the comix medium, the panels act as a sort of stamps. In one quick glance, the readers know that the rabbi in ‘A contract with God' is angry, because he raises his arms up to the skies. Pending shoulders, a hanging head: the character is sad. A spiral above the head: confusion. According to this view of comix, there is a one-to-one relationship between the signs on paper and the depicted emotions. What you see is what you get. Not so in Cages. McKean alternates instantly legible, unambiguous panels with panels fully open to polysemy. Thus, in Cages, an ordinary conversation in a jazz club, with easily identifiable characters and dialogues, quite naturally can evolve into in a phantasy play of more abstract images. Or, upon leaving the club, a tipsy Sabarski can see undefinable white areas floating across the nocturnal sky. The attraction of this approach of comix is that McKean's images are so open, that one can read them time and time again. Instead of the "empty" diagram panels of Eisner c.s., which reveal their secret straight away, some images from Cages can haunt the back of one's head for years. Like the cat on the opening pages of Cages, they creep through one's memory, waiting for the right moment to unexpectedly jump to the fore.

This trust in the expressiveness of images is central to the attraction of Cages - and to the magic of visual narration in the best sense of the word. The panels express emotions where mere words scarcely say anything anymore. What all too often leads to empty posing with self-contained graphic art, can work miracles in the coherent panel series of comix. In this respect, the ending of Cages says it all. McKean concludes his gem of a book with the image of a monochrome painting, on which Sabarski has commented earlier: "I think there's one of these black canvases in every museum in the world. They must come with the building. ‘Here's the lease, here's the key, and here's the large matt-black painting with the free, incomprehensible title.'" Seen by itself, in a museum on the wall, such a black image all too easily amounts to vacuous artiness. As the conclusion of Cages, on the other hand, its meaning is irrevocable: a monumentally black full stop that carries all previous images with it. And then even a black monochrome image can be devastatingly beautiful.

Toon Dohmen